Begging for Reviews: Scroll Two Pages and Leave One

Begging for reviews is the subject of this Short video for authors, sellers and readers who see review requests. This video addresses the unethical practice of incentivized reviews on platforms like Amazon. The full transcription and questions and answers follow the video.

This video first went up on YouTube on July 23, 2025. The written post was added on November 21, 2026.

Watch on YouTube

Is Begging for Reviews Ethical?

Begging for reviews can cross an ethical line, in Loren Weisman’s view, when it uses words the person does not mean to sell more. An author asking for truthful reviews while telling readers to scroll two Kindle pages, so it looks like they bought the book, may not be inviting anyone to read it.

  • Asking for a genuine review while coaching readers to scroll two pages can read as a contradiction and a sad sign of where things are.
  • Telling readers to scroll two pages of a Kindle book or ebook may be meant to make it look like they genuinely bought it.
  • A real request for a review can invite people to read the whole book and see what they think.
  • Some people may beg and plead for reviews and use words they do not mean as tactics to sell more.

Begging for Reviews: The Full Transcription

An Email Asking for Reviews

Not going to name the author but I really want to. I received this email and it was this is my new book and I really want reviews. I want honest reviews. And then it states leave an honest review.

Next to leave an honest review it states scroll through the Kindle if you purchase the Kindle or the ebook two pages so that then it knows that you genuinely bought it. So in a sense this author, this scam artist is stating oh scroll through too so you can leave an honest review.

Begging and Pleading for Reviews

Is there any invitation to please read and see what you think of the whole thing? It is sad in where we’ve come and the way that people will just beg and plead for reviews.

They’ll use words they don’t even mean to try to get tactics to sell that much more. Leave an honest review but make sure you just scroll two pages. That’s not too honest and it’s kind of sad. That’s where we’re at as a whole today.


What to Stop Doing in My Talks

What to legally, technically, ethically and morally stop doing with your brand now.


Questions and Answers

What is the difference between asking for reviews and begging for them?

The difference can be whether the request invites people to read the whole book and see what they think. Begging and pleading for reviews, with instructions meant to make a purchase look genuine, may use words the person does not mean to sell more.

Why do some authors tell readers to scroll pages before reviewing?

Some authors may tell readers to scroll through two pages so the Kindle or ebook registers them as someone who genuinely bought the book. A request like that can be a tactic to get reviews and sell more rather than an invitation to read, in Loren Weisman’s view.

Are incentivized or manipulated Amazon reviews unethical?

Incentivized reviews on platforms like Amazon can be an unethical practice, especially when authors have readers simulate genuine purchases. Reviews gathered that way may be fake, and the way some people beg and plead for reviews can be a sad sign of where things are.


More Videos and the Podcast

Loren Weisman is a Brand Communications and Optics Strategist who specializes in illuminating authoritative intelligence and amplifying authentic experts.

Weisman is the host of the brand communications and optics podcast Wait What Really OK.

Begging for Reviews: Scroll Two Pages and Leave One