Cookie Cutter Coaching: Templates Over Discovery

Cookie cutter coaching is the subject of this Short video for business owners weighing a coach or a business expert. The full transcription and questions and answers follow the video.

This video first went up on YouTube on July 28, 2025. The written post was added on November 22, 2026.

Watch on YouTube

How Do You Spot Cookie Cutter Coaching?

Cookie cutter coaching can show up when a coach arrives with a template page and skips discovery about your experience, your knowledge and your business. Promises about your results from someone who knows nothing about you, your product or your area may be dangerous, in Loren Weisman’s view.

  • Good athletic trainers often study an athlete’s strengths, weaknesses, body, diet and work ethic before building a plan.
  • Many certified life coaches and business experts may work from a little template page and skip discovery.
  • Promises of tenfold sales from someone who knows nothing about your business can be dangerous.
  • A coach or strategist whose plan is built for you, not taken from a workbook, may be the kind worth looking for.

Cookie Cutter Coaching: The Full Transcription

A Template or a Plan for You?

Is it an overused template or is it something designed specifically for you? My name is Loren Weisman. I’m a brand communications and optics strategist.

And maybe if you looked at certain coaches when it comes to athletics or sports, these coaches and these trainers, they look to see where are they strong, where are they weak, what do they need help in, where are they excelling, and then from there understanding their body, their diet, their chemistry, their work ethic, they put together the plan to amplify the most out of that athlete.

The Little Template Page

The same thing to me should be there when it comes to these business coaches, these strategists, and for those that choose it, even the life coaches. But too often it’s not. These people come in with their little certified programs.

They’re a certified life coach or certified business expert. And they have this little template page. If X then why. They don’t spend time in the discovery.

Promises Without Knowing You

They don’t spend time exploring, understanding what is your experience, what is your knowledge, what have you done. No, it’s these sales training people, too. I guarantee your your sales will go ten fold. You know nothing about me.

You know nothing about the product I sell. You know nothing about the area I’m in. You know nothing about my abilities. And yet you make these promises.

It’s dangerous.

Finding a Coach Who Does the Discovery

So, if you’re looking at a coach, if you’re looking at a strategist to work with, make sure like a true authoritative athletic trainer, they are spending the time discovering and exploring who you are, what you do, what you’ve done, what you can do, and putting together a plan that is not some template that came out of a workbook, but that is a plan and a system and a strategy specifically for you.


Discovery in My Talks

Going through a Discovery and Messaging Audit for yourself or with another.


Questions and Answers

What is cookie cutter coaching?

Cookie cutter coaching can mean a template plan applied to clients without discovery. The coach, often with a certification, may follow an if this, then that page instead of exploring your experience, your knowledge and what you have done.

What does a good business coach do before making a plan?

A good business coach may first learn where you are strong, where you are weak and where you are excelling, much like an athletic trainer. Spending time discovering who you are, what you do, what you have done and what you can do can come before building a plan, in Loren Weisman’s view.

Why can big coaching promises be dangerous?

Big coaching promises can be dangerous when the coach making them knows nothing about you, the product you sell, the area you are in or your abilities. Sales trainers who promise tenfold sales without any discovery may be one example.


More Videos and the Podcast

Loren Weisman is a Brand Communications and Optics Strategist who specializes in illuminating authoritative intelligence and amplifying authentic experts.

Weisman is the host of the brand communications and optics podcast Wait What Really OK.

Cookie Cutter Coaching: Templates Over Discovery