Can You Trust Documentaries? Dig a Little Deeper

The question can you trust documentaries is the subject of this video for viewers who take what they see in a documentary as fact. The full transcription and questions and answers follow the video.

This video first went up on YouTube on June 10, 2025. The written post was added on November 15, 2026.

Watch on YouTube

Can You Trust Documentaries to Tell the Full Truth?

When people ask can you trust documentaries, the answer may be not always, since many tell the story their makers want told, in Loren Weisman’s view. Some can be ethical and tell the full story, but a documentary may not work as substantiation. Digging a little deeper into whether the people interviewed are genuine experts and who the executive producers are can help.

  • Documentaries can be automatically assumed to be true, when many of them may not be.
  • Documentaries worked on in LA, in Loren Weisman’s experience, included fake doctors, paid off doctors and people claiming to know people they did not know.
  • A documentary may not be substantiation, and pointing to one may not help you in reality or in court.
  • Executive producers can often be the ones choosing the narrative, the story and what gets put out.
  • Looking at whether the people interviewed are genuine experts and professionals who would know the subject can help.

Can You Trust Documentaries: The Full Transcription

I Saw It on a Documentary

A Short lived two season show called Avenue 5. Woman says after hearing about something that she didn’t know was true. Said I saw it on a documentary, but I just thought it was a documentary.

My name is Loren Weisman, I’m a brand communications and optics strategist. I found that really funny because all too often it seems that documentaries are automatically assumed to be true. Many documentaries are not.

Putting a Documentary Out to Fix the Optic

And the thing is that someone says, okay, how do we, how do we counterbalance the optic? How do we problem solve? How do we do, you know, preventative maintenance to response? Oh, we’ll put a documentary out because that’ll fool people for whatever reason.

There are a number of people out there that, well, they see the cameras, they see a series of different cuts, nice lights, nice interviews, a whole bunch of people that may have no authority whatsoever, but they’re making a claim or backing aside and because it’s a documentary, they’re selling it as a truth.

What I Saw Working on Documentaries in LA

I’ve been a part of documentaries when I was in LA and it was really amazing to me because I thought documentaries meant, okay, this has to be absolutely objectively true, this has to be proven. And it wasn’t.

I mean, everything from fake doctors to paid off doctors to people that were brought in that didn’t know people they were claiming they knew it was as fictional as anything else on TV or like a lot of that reality TV stuff. The point being, when you see something that’s a documentary, please consider either one not using that as substantiation.

Oh well, there’s a documentary on it, it’s not going to help you in reality and it’s not going to help you in court to try to prove something there. Secondly, dig a little bit deeper.

Who Chooses the Narrative

Yes, there are documentaries that have truth to them. There are some that are ethical, that are moral, that are genuine, that are telling the full story and sometimes telling both sides of the story, but the majority of them out there are not.

They’re telling the story that wants to be told. And when you look across the executive producer list many times those are the people that are choosing the narrative, the story and what they want to put out there.

A Band Documentary and What Was Left Out

I’m not trying to ruffle any feathers, but when you look at certain extended documentaries, and I’m not knocking the Beatles, I love the Beatles, but that Beatles documentary that came out in a series of these different things, you look along there, here’s Ringo as a producer, here’s Paul as a producer, here’s however many decades later, let’s squash a whole bunch of issues and just share what we want people to see.

I mean, yeah, there were little fights and arguments and John didn’t show up, but it really, when you watch the thing against the genuine history, the people that were there, the ones that experienced them in the studio, in the rehearsals, against what was shown, and see, oh, this wasn’t about Ringo, or this wasn’t about this or this.

No, that footage was left out, or it was edited in a certain way to appear a certain way to deliver the intended story that they wanted out there with the trending, with the optics, with the narrative. So again, I’m not knocking all of them, I’m not saying that all of them are not true.

Looking at Who Is Being Interviewed

However, dig a little deeper and have a little bit more of an expectation that just because you see something titled as a documentary, that is not the genuine truth. And when you do look toward a documentary, look to the individuals that are being interviewed.

Are these genuine experts, professionals, people that would actually know? Or is this a beautifully put together, well lit, great sound, great interviews, looks great, except in that it’s staying as far from the truth.

It’s staying as far away from the truth as possible. So have that thought, dig a little bit deeper. That’s all I got.


Stories That Leave Out the Truth in My Talks

Watching out for the 75 to 25 hype stories from people that are not lying, but leaving out a lot of the truth.


Questions and Answers

Are documentaries always factual?

Documentaries may not always be factual, and many can tell the story that wants to be told. Some can be ethical, genuine and tell the full story, sometimes both sides, but nice lights, cuts and interviews may be used to sell a claim as truth.

Can a documentary be used as proof of something?

A documentary may not work as substantiation, and pointing to one may not help you in reality or in court when trying to prove something. Digging a little deeper can help, since a title that says documentary may not be a sign of the genuine truth.

How can you tell if a documentary is reliable?

Looking at the people being interviewed can help, asking whether they are genuine experts and professionals who would know the subject. Looking across the executive producer list may also help, since those people can often be the ones choosing the narrative and what gets shown.

Why do some people put out a documentary to fix their image?

Some people may put out a documentary to counterbalance an optic, expecting it to fool people. Cameras, cuts, lighting and interviews with people who may have no authority can be used to sell a claim as truth because it carries the documentary label.

How can editing change the story a documentary tells?

Editing can leave footage out or arrange it to appear a certain way, delivering the intended story. An extended documentary series about a famous band, produced in part by band members decades later, may leave out issues that show up when it is compared with the accounts of people who were there in the studio.


More Videos and the Podcast

Loren Weisman is a Brand Communications and Optics Strategist who specializes in illuminating authoritative intelligence and amplifying authentic experts.

Weisman is the host of the brand communications and optics podcast Wait What Really OK.

Can You Trust Documentaries? Dig a Little Deeper